Keep an Eye Out for The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe (1972)


For reasons known only to the movie gods, Hollywood embarked on a decades-long love affair with the idea of grabbing the rights to successful French-language comedies and remaking them for American audiences, most often with all the quirkiness and local flavor completely sanded away in the process. There were enough hits peppered in this wave to make it profitable for a while; heck, Touchstone almost had a cottage industry with it thanks to 3 Men and a Baby (1987) and its sequel, based more or less on Coline Serreau’s Three Men and a Cradle (1985) but with a ridiculous crime subplot thrown in, and to a much lesser extent, My Father the Hero (1994), a retooling of Gérard Lauzier’s Mon père, ce héros (1991). Then we have the odd case of Yves Robert’s The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe (Le grand blond avec une chaussure noir) (1972), a wildly successful star vehicle for French comic actor Pierre Richard that turned into The Man with One Red Shoe (1985), an early showcase for Tom Hanks just after his star-making turns in Splash and Bachelor Party in 1984. The American version actually isn’t too bad on its own terms, but it really can’t hold a shaky violin bow compared to the original.

The idea of a man mistakenly ID’d as a spy had already become the stuff of baroque self-parody by this point thanks to Alfred Hitchcock’s North by Northwest (1959), but this variation is a particularly clever one devised by screenwriter Francis Veber, who would become the king of French comedy remakes thanks to La Cage aux Folles (1978) / The Birdcage (1996), La chevre (1981) / Pure Luck (1991), The Dinner Game (1998) / Dinner for Schmucks (2010), and Le jouet (1976) / The Toy (1982), not to mention his writing and directing of both versions of Three Fugitives (1986 and 1989). Hollywood even tried to give him a shot at doing an original project with the gay-themed mismatched buddy cop movie Partners (1982), but that didn’t quite go as planned.

Here we get an amusing riff on the Hitchcock formula that also taps into that feeling you get as a little kid playing spy games with your friends. The gist is that a hapless, Stravinsky-loving violinist named François Perrin (Pierre Richard) gets caught up without his knowledge in a war between two upper level espionage officials (Bernard Blier and Jean Rochefort) vying for a senior position with the agency. François’s weird, at first inexplicable habit of wearing different colored shoes (one black, one brown) makes him a natural target to turn into a decoy, with his clueless reactions to the covert mayhem around him resulting in one comic mishap after another. It’s all light as a feather, of course, but the execution is so breezy and endearing you’d have to be a serious grouch not to be caught up in the hijinks.

One of the real pleasures of this film for music buffs is the highly unexpected but pitch-perfect score by the great Vladimir Cosma, whose name appears on a wave of films by this film’s writer and director. Though perfectly adroit in all genres, he really excelled at farcical comedy and knew how to generate just the right kind of earworm to keep the movie in your head for days after leaving the theater. In America he’s probably best known for his hip, percussive music that wove in and out of the opera selections in Jean-Jacques Beineix’s Diva (1981), but his prodigious, Morricone-level output (over two hundred feature films!) is a real treasure chest. It’s worth noting that one of his biggest hits in the 1970s was his soundtrack to another big international French crossover favorite one year later, The Mad Adventures of Rabbi Jacob (1973), the closest thing to a U.S. calling card for the brilliant Louis de Funès. What makes his score for The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe stand out is its inventive variety of textures, working in bouncy Eastern European strings and an infectious pan flute motif performed by none other than Gheorghe Zamfir, a.k.a. “the king of the pan flute,” who would become an infomercial standby for years and performed the eerie main theme for Peter Weir’s haunting Picnic at Hanging Rock (1975). Besides, how can you possibly resist a soundtrack with a track called “Mozart Massacre?”

A massive hit in both France and the United States, this film turned into a major calling card for Yves Robert, who soon scored another hit with the sexier Pardon Mon Affaire (1976) and its sequel one year later, which was naturally Americanized as The Woman in Red (1984) with Gene Wilder. A busy actor as well in his own right, Robert would go on to score big on the American art house circuit with the lovely My Father’s Glory and My Mother’s Castle (both 1990), both of which also featured intoxicating Cosma scores.


Blond, frizzy-haired star Pierre Richard is considered one of the great comedic treasures of French cinema, but for some reason he never really hopped over to Hollywood despite the popularity of this film and its frothy sequel, The Return of the Tall Blond Man (Le retour du grand blond) (1974). Blessed with wildly expressive eyes and one of the biggest smiles to ever stretch across a movie screen, he’s the kind of guy you can’t help rooting for (and he still enjoys a very busy career in French cinema). His first big breakthrough film was a supporting role in another wonderful little comedy by Robert, Very Happy Alexander (Alexandre le bienheureux) (1968), which you can track down as a very low-priced, all-region French Blu-ray with English subtitles if you’re interested (along with some of his later films, most of which have yet to get decent American releases). Fortunately you can see his high water mark as well as the giddy La moutarde me monte au nez (1974) (a funny French expression about mustard getting on your nose, inelegantly translated for Yanks as I’m Losing My Temper) right here streaming on Filmstruck as part of the Starring Pierre Richard theme through June 9, 2017.

Nathaniel Thompson

6 Responses Keep an Eye Out for The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe (1972)
Posted By Emgee : February 22, 2017 3:25 pm

“Pardon Mon Affaire (1976) and its sequel one year later, which was naturally Americanized as The Woman in Red (1984) with Gene Wilder.”

In fact Pardon Mon Affaire or , to give it its original title Un éléphant ça trompe énormément, was the movie The Woman in Red was based on. The sequel was Nous irons tous au paradis or Pardon Mon Affaire, Too! (really imaginative guys….)

For those who’ve cringed at The Woman in Red, these movies are really good, as is The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe.

In fact: merveilleux!

Posted By artfrankmiami : February 22, 2017 3:27 pm

You said about Three Men and a Baby that it was “based more or less on Coline Serreau’s Three Men and a Cradle (1985) but with a ridiculous crime subplot thrown in”.

As I recall the original French version also had a ridiculous crime subplot with the drugs and kidnapping, it was just played more comedically in the American version. After seeing both, I felt the French movie was a better movie as a comedy drama, but it was dulled by lack of (to me as an American possibly) star power which had an added weight to it on the whole. Maybe if I was more familiar with the French actors?

I love the gonzo nature of The Man with One Red Shoe but I had seen The Man with One Black Shoe on cable in both dubbed and subtitled versions. For me, the most I can recall from the experience of it was, there’s a lot of missing dialogue in subtitled movies but I prefer to hear the foreign language performance and read the subtitles.

Posted By artfrankmiami : February 22, 2017 3:38 pm

I didn’t read the full article when I made my comment, so I am happy you mentioned The Mad Adventures of Rabbi Jacob (1973), Louis de Funès. When is that going to be on TCM? and why not dig up Fantomas? In Miami, ask any Cuban who had grown up in Fidel’s 1960′s Cuba before escaping saw only Russian and French movies, and most know who Fantomas is. I’ve only found one on VHS back in the late 80s for rental only, but I would love that there’s a Louis de Funes day on TCM…

Sorry FilmStruck, I pay too much already for cable.

Posted By swac44 : February 22, 2017 5:18 pm

Thanks to living in bilingual Canada, you can often find these films available on DVD thanks to the enormous audience they enjoyed in Quebec. Unfortunately, probably due to copyright or regional issues, they are frequently released here without English subtitles. I can speak some French, and read it fairly well, but my oral comprehension is, how you say, comme ci comme ça.

I was surprised to see The Mad Adventures of “Rabbi” Jacob received a North American release via 20th Century Fox. Not sure if that version was dubbed into English or not, but I suspect that it probably was.

Posted By artfrankmiami : February 22, 2017 6:29 pm

I saw it in the theater, with subtitles, I think late 70s. I had always heard throughout the 80s that the video release was held up in America over some sort of rights issues.

Posted By EricJ : February 22, 2017 6:59 pm

I’ve seen the Hanks version but not the Veber version–
And I can see the bits of French movie in it, in that Richard is supposed to be, in the truest French-comedy tradition, the Unkillable Idiot: The complete dunce who manages to survive everything, because luck, accident, and innocent/creative stupidity are implausibly on his side.
(Rather like Roberto Benigni played in his early pre-Life Is Beautiful comedies, like Johnny Stecchino or Il Monstro.)

Hanks, OTOH, was the usual Likable Hipster that he played after Splash and before Dragnet, and just seemed like a cool slacker wandering through the spy follies.
The Unkillable Idiot has to initially be completely UNAWARE that dangerous things are happening to him, the Likable Hipster, you’re just wondering why he isn’t, already.

Leave a Reply

Current ye@r *

As of November 1, 2017 FilmStruck’s blog, StreamLine, has moved to Tumblr.

Please visit us there!

 Streamline is the official blog of FilmStruck, a new subscription service that offers film aficionados a comprehensive library of films including an eclectic mix of contemporary and classic art house, indie, foreign and cult films.