“I wonder if my brother remembers his brother?” – Remembering Eli Wallach 1915-2014


“I wonder if my brother remembers his brother?”
- Tuco (Eli Wallach) in THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY (1966)

We lost Eli Wallach on June 24th at the ripe old age of 98. The talented actor was beloved by film fans and fellow actors so quickly cobbled together obituaries as well as many heartfelt tributes have begun flooding the World Wide Web. It’s with much trepidation that I tip my own toe into these grief-filled waters but since hearing the news I haven’t been able to get Wallach out of my head. The Brooklyn born son of Jewish parents who immigrated to America from Poland appeared in over 150 films and television productions including BABY DOLL (1956), THE LINEUP (1958), SEVEN THIEVES (1960), THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN (1960), THE MISFITS (1961), HOW THE WEST WAS WON (1962), THE VICTORS (1963), LORD JIM (1965), THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY (1966), THE TIGER MAKES OUT (1967), ACE HIGH (1968) and THE PEOPLE NEXT DOOR (1970), which are just a few early highlights from his lengthy body of work. And while it’s difficult to point to a favorite role in a career as vast and varied as Wallach’s I can’t deny that his unforgettable turn as the grinning bandito in THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY has had the biggest and most long-lasting impact on me. It’s a film I first saw nearly 40 years ago with my father when I was just an impressionable kid and much like THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN (another favorite Wallach film), THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY is a movie that I have returned to countless times and each viewing experience becomes richer and more rewarding.

I’m not alone in my enthusiasm for the film and in the days following Wallach’s death there have been numerous references made to his unforgettable performance as Tuco. Many are enthusiastic but some sources such as The New York Times casually disregarded it as “Sergio Leone’s so-called spaghetti western” without acknowledging the incredible acting Wallach does in the film. It’s worth remembering that Leone’s movie was critically dismissed during its initial release but the public loved it. Thanks to dedicated fans and fringe film writers such as Christopher Frayling, Tom Betts and William Connolly, who tirelessly navigated through the hostel critical establishment and published articles, zines and books about the often maligned genre, there’s been a re-evaluation of spaghetti westerns within the last 20 years or so. THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY is now considered a bona fide classic by many and even received a much lauded presentation at the 2010 TCM Film Festival with Eli Wallach in attendance but that recognition was hard-won.

I’ve never understood the reluctance from some to embrace these films and I’ve long considered Wallach’s Tuco to be one of the western genre’s most richly realized characters. During his career, Eli Wallach worked with many renowned directors including Elia Kazan, Don Siegel, John Sturges, Henry Hathaway, John Huston, Richard Brooks and William Wyler but some of his finest and most nuanced film acting can be found in Sergio Leone’s dust drenched ode to the wild west. In front of Leone’s unforgiving camera, the gentle Jewish boy from Brooklyn was able to completely transform himself into a violent Mexican bandito. In another actor’s less capable hands Tuco aka “The Rat” could have easily become a two-dimensional cartoon character sporting brownface and wearing a sombrero, but Wallach fully inhabited his role and gave Tuco a depth and breadth that was missing in his previous depictions of outlaws as seen in THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN and HOW THE WEST WAS WON.





Leone famously liked to shoot his actors in extreme close-up or in sweeping wide shots where they were barely visible. But Wallach instinctively knew how to make the most of his screen time and easily navigates between these two very different modes of filmmaking. His eyes speak volumes when Leone’s camera zooms in for a signature close-up but when the director’s camera is out of sight Wallach skillfully used his body language to define his character from a distance. Many actors would get lost in the vast deserts, dilapidated cemeteries and shabby old towns that make up Leone’s film but Wallach seamlessly becomes part of the landscape. We know he’s there even when we can’t see him.

Comedy, action and drama–Wallach could do it all and with Leone’s guidance he was able to really stretch his acting muscles in ways that few films allowed him to. In THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY, Wallach gets most of the film’s funniest lines and spits them out with a kind of kinetic verbosity that can make your head spin. He also effortlessly transforms himself into an action star while riding horses, jumping out of trains and blowing up bridges. But my favorite scene in THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY has no laughs or action. It also features what I consider to be some of the finest dramatic acting that I’ve ever seen from Wallach (or any actor for that matter) on screen.

The six minute scene I’m referring to takes place in a crumbling monastery where Tuco and ‘Blondie’ (Clint Eastwood) have holed-up during their relentless quest for buried treasure. Tuco’s brother is a Catholic friar named Pablo (Luigi Pistilli) and the two men haven’t seen each other in nine years. As Tuco, Wallach cautiously greets his pious brother with open arms saying, “I was just passing by here. I said to myself. . . I wonder if my brother remembers his brother?” hoping for a hug in return but Father Pablo only rolls his eyes in disgust. It quickly becomes clear that Tuco’s brother does indeed remember him and is appalled by his gruff appearance, reckless behavior and criminal lifestyle. Things take a turn for the worse when Tuco asks about their parents and learns that they both died during his absence. As his brother continues to berate him, Tuco suddenly stops playing Mr. Nice Guy and unleashes a mountain of pent-up emotion that leaves both brothers battered and bruised.

Pablo: “Outside of evil, what else have you managed to do? It seems to me you once had a wife someplace.”

Tuco: “Not one, lots of them! One here, one there, wherever I found them. Go on, preach me a sermon, Pablo.”

Pablo: “What good would that be? Just keep on the way you’re going. Go away. The Lord have mercy on your soul.”

Tuco: “I’ll go, I’ll go. While I’m waiting for the Lord to remember me . . . l, Tuco Ramirez, brother of Brother Ramirez, will tell you something. You think you’re better than I am. Where we came from, if one did not want to die of poverty one became a priest or a bandit! You chose your way, I chose mine. Mine was harder. You talk of our mother and father. You remember when you left to become a priest? I stayed behind! I must have been ten, twelve. I don’t remember which, but I stayed. I tried, but it was no good. Now I am going to tell you something. You became a priest because you were too much of a coward to do what I do!”

After their ugly confrontation, Tuco steps outside and casually greets Blondie then begins to tell a heartwarming family story about how his brother was so happy to see him. The tall tale is a lie that Tuco desperately wants to believe and Blondie indulges him.





What Wallach does within those six short minutes is flat out astonishing. Up to this point we’ve been given very little information about Tuco but by the time that scene ends we learn everything we need to know about him. Wallach allows us to see Tuco’s truth. His past, passions and motivation are presented to us in the dialogue but Wallach animates those lines with his eyes and body language bringing the character to life in a myriad of ways. His eyes dart around the room, smile in an effort to ease the tension, tear-up when overcome by grief, pierce into his brother’s soul and finally turn into vengeful daggers. The actor is constantly shifting on his feet, cocking his head and wiping his nose making it clear that his character is uncomfortable in the presence of his brother and uneasy in the sacred space offered by the monastery. It’s the kind of powerful acting that you’re used to seeing in a Kazan film but it is smack dab in the middle of a spaghetti western. Don’t believe me? I’ve posted the video evidence below. Even played out of context, the following scene manages to retain its incredible power and grace.

If you’d like to see more of Wallach and his extraordinary talents, tune into TCM on Monday June 30th. They’ve scheduled a tribute to the actor that includes screenings of some great films including BABY DOLL, THE MISFITS and HOW THE WEST WON.

Further reading:
- TCM Eli Wallach Tribute on Monday, June 30

16 Responses “I wonder if my brother remembers his brother?” – Remembering Eli Wallach 1915-2014
Posted By LD : June 26, 2014 11:05 pm

Of all Eli Wallach’s roles, Tuco is my favorite. I also saw THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY when it was initially released. I thought it was terrific then and I still do. One of my favorite scenes is when Tuco is running around the cemetery looking for Arch Stanton’s grave enhanced by Morricone’s haunting score. Not for those prone to dizziness. Then comes the showdown and the close-ups of Blondie, Angel Eyes and Tuco with his gun on a rope. And of course the music. Thank you Mr. Wallach for all your work but especially for Tuco.

Posted By Cary Watson : June 27, 2014 12:21 am

Bravo, Kimberly! I, too, am hopelessly addicted to GBU, and the scene with Tuco’s brother is one of the great moments in film acting, and it confirms that Wallach was the true star of the film. The prejudice against Leone’s westerns probably stemmed partially from chauvinism: many critics seemed to take the view that only Americans could make westerns. Here’s a piece I did on GBU that argues that it’s an allegory of God and the Devil fighting for Tuco’s soul.


Posted By Juana Maria : June 27, 2014 1:40 am

It sadden me greatly to read of Eli Wallach’s death on Tuesday. I know he lived to almost 100 yrs. It still seems too short for such a great talent. “GBU” is one of my favorite Westerns to watch, I have currently seen it close to 90 times. Ok, so I count even partial viewings of this film, but that shows how often they have this movie on TV! That and now there’s Internet. The scene with Tuco and his brother Pablo is very personal for me. Years ago, when my twin sister still lived at home we watched this film together… Only later to have her retort Tuco’s words to me. My twin had become like Tuco, a run away, a bit of an outlaw…She got up with the wrong people. I, on the other hand, have always been very religious, I consider myself devout. She called me a “goody two shoes”. We pretty much had a word for word conversation like the one in the film. She feels I don’t have the guts to go live the way she does. I think it takes greater strength to resist evil. That greater strength is from God. I have also wonder, on the subject of religion, did Wallach sign the way he does in film because he was of the Jewish faith and not Catholic? He said in an interview he learned to sign that way from Leone.

Posted By Gamera2000 : June 27, 2014 2:55 am

Couldn’t agree more about Eli Wallach’s performance as Tuco. I have seen this film dozens of times and i never fail to find the film less than riveting, and much of it is thanks to Wallach.

Watching him move across the screen, whether racing around the cemetary looking for the gold or putting a gun together at the merchant’s shop, is truly a marvel. It is funny, because when I heard he had died this scene with his brother, a life’s story in six minutes, is one of the first things I thought of.

Posted By Ghijath Naddaf : June 27, 2014 7:35 am

Also one of my favorite movies. Eli Wallach is epic in it.
His Tuco is at times such a funny guy, that you almost forget
what a murderous bastard he really is.
And than he remembers you.
I guess Martin Scorsese had a bit of Tuco in mind,when he wrote
Joe Peci´s persona in Goodfellas.

Posted By Ghijath Naddaf : June 27, 2014 9:13 am

“And than he reminds you”
Sorry for the bad english.

Posted By swac44 : June 27, 2014 2:46 pm

It’s been over a decade since the Eastwood-directed Mystic River came out, but I remember getting a little misty-eyed when Wallach turned up in a small, uncredited role as a liquor store owner. It was touching to see that Blondie hadn’t forgotten his old partner Tuco.

Posted By Susan Doll : June 27, 2014 4:38 pm

A terrific tribute to Wallach. Well done.

Posted By Maryann : June 28, 2014 12:19 am

Thanks for giving me a new perspective on his performance in this film, I look forward to viewing it with fresh eyes.

Posted By Tommy Gibbons : June 29, 2014 3:52 am

“When you have to shoot, shoot, don’t talk.”
Wallach etched his roles with a depth of idiosyncrasies that today’s assembly-line actors and filmmakers rarely approach.
Eli, you touched us…
and to my 90-year-old film loving dad, the gift of GBU to a nine-year-old mind is a blessed treasure. It will never fade to black.

Posted By MONICA CORDOVA : July 2, 2014 3:10 am

The world has lost another unforgettable actor, the great Eli Wallach. I have admired Mr. Wallach’s acting for many years and Tuco will always be one of my favorite characters in film. I have seen GBU at least 25 times and will continue to watch the film when I am in the mood for a great western. Eli Wallach, Clint Eastwood, Hugo Montenegro’s soundtrack – simply the best. Thank you, Kimberly L. for your post.

Posted By Cusser : July 2, 2014 7:00 pm

That’s Ennio Morricone’s soundtrack !!!

Posted By Juana Maria : July 15, 2014 5:08 pm

Cusser: I know it was Ennio Morricone too. Glad you said something. Thanks, that was bugging me. Ha ha.

Posted By Tamsin Parker : May 31, 2016 8:04 pm

I like to think that Eli had ben sent to Eath from Heaven, and when his time came, Heaven took him back.
Tuco was the very first role and for a start, I never laughed so hard at a movie in all my life and it was thanks to him. Wallach truly gave us one of the greatest movie characters of all time. Funny, sympathetic and morally conflicted.
Tuco also meant a lot to me, personally, because he was the first movie character I can remember who helped me to fully understand myself. I’m clumsy, loud, garrulous, abrasive, muffin-topped and pigeon toed. I am an extrovert with Asperger’s and therefore something of a misfit. The thing we had most in common was that we talked and acted without thinking first, or sometimes forgot to check important details. I fhad finally found a movie character I could relate to, even though I’m not a criminal and he’s not autistic (or pigeon toed). So I thank Eli for giving us this amazing performance of this incredible character.

Posted By Tamsin Parker : May 31, 2016 8:05 pm

Earth, I meant!

Posted By Tamsin Parker : April 24, 2017 5:24 am

I’m also convinced his skin was naturally olive coloured.

Leave a Reply

Current ye@r *

We regret to inform you that FilmStruck is now closed.  Our last day of service was November 29, 2018.

Please visit tcm.com/help for more information.

We would like to thank our many fans and loyal customers who supported us.  FilmStruck was truly a labor of love, and in a world with an abundance of entertainment options – THANK YOU for choosing us.